Painful Quandary
Scars of Mirrodin · #73

Painful Quandary

Painful Quandary is a Rare Enchantment from Scars of Mirrodin (73) in Magic: The Gathering. Mana cost {3}{B}{B}. Color identity: B. Cactaur's latest catalog snapshot shows a market reference near $17.87 for ungraded copies.

Scars of Mirrodin set collectorsRarity-focused collectorsPrice-conscious singles buyers [object Object][object Object][object Object][object Object][object Object][object Object]
TCGPlayer market $17.87
Cardmarket trend €1.10
Rarity Rare
App coming soon

Who is this card for?

Painful Quandary suits collectors and players working on Scars of Mirrodin who need the Rare slot. Compare listing photos to your target finish and confirm the Scryfall collector number before buying online.

What is Painful Quandary from Scars of Mirrodin?

Painful Quandary is a Enchantment in Scars of Mirrodin numbered 73. Mana cost {3}{B}{B}. Color identity: B. Painful Quandary (73) from Scars of Mirrodin should be evaluated with set context, mana cost, color identity, and condition together. This printing is from Scars of Mirrodin.

What is Painful Quandary worth today?

Cactaur tracks a market reference near $17.87 for Painful Quandary. Low and high spread runs $17.87 to null. Per-finish references: cardmarket: $1.10; foil: $17.87; Normal: $2.07. This printing is from Scars of Mirrodin. Collector number 73 distinguishes this printing from same-name cards in other sets.

SetScars of Mirrodin
Number73
RarityRare
TCGPlayer USD$17.87
Cardmarket EUR€1.10
cardmarket $1.10
foil $17.87
Normal $2.07

Card stats

ColorsB

How collectible is Painful Quandary?

Painful Quandary is a Rare printing in Scars of Mirrodin. Master set builders use collector number and set symbol to track completion progress. This printing is from Scars of Mirrodin. Collector number 73 distinguishes this printing from same-name cards in other sets.

What are the key details for Painful Quandary?

Painful Quandary lists as Enchantment. Artist: Whit Brachna. Rules text is indexed in the catalog for search and deck research. This printing is from Scars of Mirrodin. Collector number 73 distinguishes this printing from same-name cards in other sets. Catalogued rarity: Rare.

Cactaur's take

Painful Quandary (73) from Scars of Mirrodin should be evaluated with set context, mana cost, color identity, and condition together.

Pros

  • Painful Quandary is catalogued as Rare Enchantment in Scars of Mirrodin, making set and collector number verification straightforward.
  • Public market data shows a reference near $17.87 across finishes (cardmarket: $1.10; foil: $17.87; Normal: $2.07).
  • Mana cost {3}{B}{B} and type line Enchantment help deck builders confirm the correct printing quickly.

Cons

  • Raw market prices vary by condition and finish — near-mint estimates are not slab grades.

Verdict: Use $17.87 as a benchmark, then adjust for finish, grade, and how quickly you need to buy or sell.

FAQ

What is Painful Quandary from Scars of Mirrodin?

Painful Quandary is a Rare Enchantment from Scars of Mirrodin numbered 73 in Magic: The Gathering. Cactaur indexes set, rarity, mana cost, and market references for this printing.

How much is Painful Quandary worth?

Cactaur's catalog snapshot shows a market reference near $17.87 for ungraded Painful Quandary. Condition, finish, and recent sold comps can move realized prices above or below that benchmark.

What rarity is Painful Quandary?

Painful Quandary is catalogued as Rare in Scars of Mirrodin. Use the collector number and set symbol on listings to confirm you are buying this exact printing.

Is Painful Quandary legal in Commander or Standard?

Painful Quandary shows format legality in standard, future, historic, timeless based on our latest ingest. Always verify the exact printing and ban-list updates before registering a deck for an event.

Should I buy Painful Quandary near mint or played?

Near-mint copies command the catalog reference near $17.87. Heavily played copies trade lower unless the card is a chase rare where any clean copy is scarce.

Related cards

Trust & data sources. Cactaur displays catalog and market data from pokemontcg.io embedded TCGPlayer/Cardmarket references. Prices change frequently and are not guarantees.

Cactaur does not authenticate cards or guarantee values. Scan your copy in the iPhone app for condition-aware guidance.

Catalog snapshot: 2026-06-23. Last updated: 2026-06-23.